Medicare for All. Not healthcare profiteering for the few.

Two prominent candidates for the Democratic presidential nomination are not just opposing Medicare for All – they keep denouncing and distorting it.


Pete Buttigieg and Joe Biden have opened up a double-barreled assault on Medicare for All. They’re touting “public option” plans that would leave huge numbers of Americans uninsured or underinsured. And those plans don’t make economic sense.


Buttigieg is using the slogan “Medicare for all who want it,” which might sound good. But, as New Hampshire State Representative Mark King points out, “the idea of a public option such as ‘Medicare for all who want it’ continues to benefit the private insurance companies that can pick and choose who they cover. It would set the public option up for failure – and unfairly burden taxpayers – by inequitably shouldering the cost for those remaining, those most in need of healthcare.”

Representative King adds: “This concept that a public option plan can deliver just, universal health coverage is disingenuous. In sharp contrast, the core tenet making Medicare for All viable is that it includes all of us. This gives true Medicare for All bargaining power to keep costs down, while distributing the risk across a massive population pool.”

Sadly, Buttigieg is claiming that Medicare for All would dump people off of health coverage and deprive them of “choice.” Those are insurance-industry talking points. He is deliberately confusing the current “choice” of predatory for-profit insurance plans with the genuine full choice of healthcare providers that enhanced Medicare for everyone would offer.

Meanwhile, Biden has been using scare tactics and sending out messages like this absurd tweet: “Let’s put this in perspective: if you eliminate every single solitary soldier, tank, satellite, nuclear weapon, eliminate the Pentagon and it would only pay for 4 months of Medicare for All. 4 months. Where do the other 8 months come from? Your paycheck.”

That’s not the kind of leadership we need for healthcare in our country.

“Medicare for All has the potential to achieve major cost savings in its operations relative to the existing U.S. healthcare system. We estimate that, through implementation of Medicare for All, overall U.S. healthcare costs could fall by about 19 percent relative to the existing system.”
Economic Analysis of Medicare for All, Political Economy Research Institute, University of Massachusetts / Amherst, 2018

“The efficiencies of a single-payer system would make universal coverage affordable and give everyone in the United States their free choice of doctors and hospitals. But that goal will remain out of reach if private insurers are allowed to continue gaming the system.... Some proposals, including those by Joe Biden and Pete Buttigieg, would offer a Medicare-like public plan for sale alongside private plans on the insurance exchanges now available under the Affordable Care Act. These buy-in reforms would minimize the need for new taxes, since most enrollees would be charged premiums. But tens of millions would remain uninsured or with coverage so skimpy, they still couldn’t afford care.”
– Dr. David Himmelstein and Dr. Steffie Woolhandler, cofounders of Physicians for a National Health Plan, writing in The Nation, October 21, 2019

“With costs rising painfully, insurance companies denying care and nearly 30 million people still uninsured, America desperately needs an honest health policy discussion. That’s why it has been so disappointing over the past several weeks to watch multiple candidates parrot right-wing attacks on ‘Medicare for All,’ like claiming that it will greatly increase spending on healthcare or ringing alarms about raising taxes on the middle class.

“The truth is the opposite: Medicare for All would sharply reduce overall spending on healthcare. It can be thoughtfully designed to reduce total costs for the vast majority of American families, while improving the quality of the care they get.

“Over my career, I have witnessed the problems with our healthcare system firsthand. As a pediatrician, I have seen how our fragmented, expensive system hurts children and families. As a researcher at Harvard Medical School, I have studied the causes of waste and overspending in our system. And as President Barack Obama’s head of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, I led the existing Medicare system and helped stand up Obamacare....

“The case for Medicare for All is simple. It would cover everyone – period.... [I]t would be simpler, easing the onerous burdens of billing for doctors, endless paperwork for all healthcare professionals, and navigating the confusing coverage system for patients and families. Compared with some candidates’ plans that retain our patchwork of coverage, Medicare for All wins twice: on both simplicity and savings....

“The country deserves a real debate about healthcare – not one that misleads Americans about how public financing of healthcare would affect them. A real debate would show that Medicare for All, though not a perfect solution, is the best option we have to get healthcare costs and quality back on track, lifting an exhausting burden off American families and businesses.”

– Dr. Donald M. Berwick, the administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services in the Obama administration, writing in USA Today on October 22, 2019

________________________________

This informational flier (PDF) was not authorized or funded by any candidate or campaign organization. It was entirely produced and financed by Action for a Progressive Future / RootsAction.org. For further information, call or text to 415-488-3606.



 
 
Step Aside Joe graphic 01
RAEF donation Sustainer button
Progressive Hub logo
Defuse Nuclear War
No War in Ukraine

RA tshirt 6 issuesTwitter social icons - rounded square - bluefacebook-square-iconyoutube logo rgb lightInstagram logo 2016 132x132fourth wall justicemug 2

Search

TESTIMONIALS

  • For the last decade, RootsAction.org has done the essential daily work of helping to grow progressive movements from the grassroots. RootsAction organizes strategically in support of big reforms that our country needs – such as Medicare for All, a Green New Deal, police accountability, workers’ rights, fair taxation of giant corporations and the super-wealthy, real diplomacy and an end to forever wars. RootsAction is the kind of steadfast ally that progressives in Congress need when we're challenging entrenched power. -- Congressman Ro Khanna